When the Silence is the Data

Several years into my global operations work, I was sent to assess a manufacturing facility overseas that had been performing adequately; not failing, not thriving, just holding steady in a way that concealed a great deal of unrealized potential. The numbers were acceptable. The real story was in the silence.

In that plant, as in many I encountered in certain parts of the world, the cultural relationship to authority was fundamentally different from what I had grown up in. Hierarchy was not just an organizational chart. It was a code of conduct. Workers did not volunteer problems to managers. Managers did not admit uncertainty to their superiors. The flow of information was careful, upward, and highly edited. People were skilled, disciplined, and almost entirely unexpressed.

I had been in enough plants by then to recognize what a suppressed workforce looks like. The work gets done. The shifts change on time. But no one asks a question that might reveal a gap, and no one offers an idea that might be rejected. The organization is operating at a fraction of what its people could give.

The standard response, the one I had been trained in, was to run workshops, introduce improvement methodologies, and set new performance targets. I tried some of that. It landed like a foreign language, because that is exactly what it was.

What eventually worked was much simpler. I started asking to be taught.

I asked team members to walk me through their processes as if I had never seen them before; because I hadn’t, not their version of them. I asked what the hardest part of the job was and waited, genuinely, for an answer rather than filling the silence with my own assumptions. When someone pointed out a problem, I said thank you before I said anything else. Slowly, incrementally, the silences changed in quality. People began to say what they actually thought.

The performance gains that followed were real and measurable. But what I carry from that experience is not the numbers. It is the understanding that the most powerful thing a leader can do at a cultural crossroads is relinquish the posture of expert and take up the posture of student. In every culture I have ever worked in, people respond to being genuinely asked. Being heard is a universal need, and a leader who creates space for it will always find more to work with than one who doesn’t.

Kathy Miller is a keynote speaker, certified leadership coach, and business transformation advisor. Kathy is a recognized senior business executive with a proven track record in developing and leading operations that deliver results. 

EMAIL Newsletter

MORE Mindset and Mechanics

We know that life’s challenges are unique and complex for everyone. Sign-up for Kathy’s email newlsetter to receive insights to your inbox.